Not without a validation order, and not just to keep them quiet. Paying one creditor ahead of the rest while the company cannot pay all of them is a preference, which a liquidator can unwind if the company is later wound up, and it is a disposition that is void under section 127 if an order follows. Where the payment is genuinely necessary for the business to keep trading, it belongs in the validation order application, where the court will permit it on that basis.
Preference
A payment that puts a creditor in a better position than it would otherwise have been in, made while the company could not pay its debts and influenced by a desire to prefer that creditor, can be set aside by a liquidator. The look-back period is six months before the winding-up began (which, for a petition, means six months before presentation), or two years where the creditor is connected with the company, in which case the desire is presumed. HMRC is not a connected creditor, but a loan from a director's relative is.
When a payment is justified
The court will validate payments that benefit the creditors as a whole, or at least do not prejudice them: wages, rent on premises the business needs, fuel, insurance, a supplier without whom the business stops, and current PAYE and VAT so that the company does not fall further behind. The test is the benefit to the business, not the pressure the creditor is applying.
HMRC in particular
Paying current tax as it falls due is ordinary-course conduct and is usually validated. Paying off old arrears to HMRC while the petition is from someone else is a preference. If HMRC is the petitioner, see paying the debt: HMRC will want the petition debt and costs in full and the returns up to date.
What to do now
- List every creditor, what is owed, when it is due, and whether the business stops without them (there is a creditor table in the Handbook's working pages).
- Put the genuinely essential payments into the validation order application with the reasons.
- Do not pay anyone else until the petition is dealt with.
- If a creditor is threatening to stop supply, tell them a validation order is being sought and when; most will wait a few days for a court order rather than lose the customer.
Where this is covered in more depth
Validation orders, HMRC petitions and the Handbook on preferences.
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition. Call 07361 999123, text DIRAID to 82228, or request a call back.
Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.
Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back
Or call us on 07361 999123
First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose
