# HMRC has sent me a personal liability notice for my company's National Insurance: what should I do?

Source: https://directoraid.co.uk/personal-liability-notice-nics.html · Last reviewed 2026-11-18 · Director Aid

**Appeal it in time if HMRC cannot prove the company's failure to pay was caused by your fraud or neglect. A personal liability notice (PLN) makes a director personally liable for the company's unpaid National Insurance, under section 121C Social Security Administration Act 1992, but HMRC bears the burden of proof and there are four statutory grounds of appeal.** Directors also ask "can HMRC make me pay my company's National Insurance?", "what is a PLN?" and "how do I appeal a personal liability notice?". This page explains the test, the appeal and the first steps.

### What a personal liability notice is

Normally a company's National Insurance contributions (NICs) are the company's debt, not yours. Section 121C is an exception. HMRC can serve a notice on an officer of the company, usually a director, requiring them to pay some or all of the unpaid contributions, with interest, where:

- the company has failed to pay contributions it was required to pay; and
- the failure appears to HMRC to be attributable to fraud or neglect on the part of one or more of its officers (the "culpable officers").

The notice must state the amount of contributions concerned, the sum you are required to pay and, where more than one officer is blamed, the proportion HMRC has applied to you. Interest runs from the date the notice is issued. If the company later pays part of the contributions, your liability is reduced accordingly.

PLNs cover National Insurance only. They do not make you liable for the company's VAT, PAYE income tax or corporation tax; HMRC has other, separate powers for those. See [am I liable for my company's tax debts?](https://directoraid.co.uk/directors-liable-company-tax-debts.html).

### When HMRC uses them

PLNs are most often issued after the company has gone into liquidation or administration and the arrears cannot be collected from it. They can also be issued while the company is still trading. HMRC usually investigates first, and may write asking for information or inviting you to an interview about why the contributions were not paid. What you say and send at that stage becomes evidence, so take advice before you answer.

The typical case HMRC pursues is a company that kept paying staff their net wages, suppliers and the directors, while leaving the National Insurance deducted from wages unpaid for a long period, especially where the director knew of the arrears and had no realistic plan to pay them.

### "Neglect": what HMRC has to show

**Fraud** means deliberately not paying with dishonest intent. **Neglect** is more common and means failing to do something a reasonably diligent director in your position would have done. The test is objective: personal difficulties are not usually an answer in themselves, but what you knew, what you did, and why are all relevant.

Points that often help a director:

- the company was paying its NICs until a sudden event (loss of a major customer, a bad debt, a funding withdrawal) and stopped trading quickly afterwards;
- you took professional advice and followed it, for example agreeing a [Time to Pay arrangement](https://directoraid.co.uk/hmrc-time-to-pay-arrangement-company.html) or acting on an insolvency practitioner's advice;
- you were not responsible for finance and had no reason to know of the arrears;
- the company had a reasonable, documented plan to pay.

Points that count against a director include paying yourself or connected creditors in preference to HMRC, ignoring HMRC letters, and a pattern of arrears through more than one company.

### How to appeal

Under section 121D you can appeal against the issue and content of the notice on four grounds:

| Ground | What it means |
|---|---|
| (a) | The whole or part of the amount is not contributions to which section 121C applies |
| (b) | The failure to pay was not attributable to any fraud or neglect on your part |
| (c) | You were not an officer of the company at the time of the alleged fraud or neglect |
| (d) | HMRC's opinion that you were the only culpable officer, or on the proportion you should pay, was unreasonable |

The appeal is made first to HMRC in writing, and can go on to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber). **The burden of proof on each ground is on HMRC** (section 121D(4)). The time limit for appealing is short: treat it as 30 days from the date of the notice and check the notice itself. A late appeal needs permission, which is not guaranteed.

**DO NOT let the appeal deadline pass while you gather documents. Lodge the appeal in time, stating the grounds, and send the evidence afterwards if necessary.**

### Evidence to gather

1. Board minutes, emails and management accounts for the period the arrears built up.
2. Correspondence with HMRC, including any Time to Pay request or arrangement.
3. Records of what was paid to whom while NICs went unpaid, including your own salary, dividends and loan account.
4. Advice you received from accountants or insolvency practitioners, and what you did with it.
5. Evidence of your role: if another director ran the finances, show it.

### What happens if you do not appeal, or lose

The sum in the notice becomes your personal debt. HMRC can enforce it like any other debt, including by a statutory demand and a bankruptcy petition against you. The same facts may also feature in an Insolvency Service investigation into your conduct; see [Insolvency Service investigation: what to do now](https://directoraid.co.uk/insolvency-service-investigation-letter-what-to-do.html).

**DO NOT transfer your home or savings to a spouse or family member to protect them from a PLN. Transfers at an undervalue can be reversed.** See [can HMRC take my house for company debts?](https://directoraid.co.uk/can-hmrc-take-my-house-company-debt.html).

### If the company is still trading

A PLN is often a late consequence of an HMRC debt that has already led to a winding-up petition. HMRC presented 57% of the winding-up petitions advertised in England and Wales since November 2023 ([Director Aid Petition Figures](https://directoraid.co.uk/how-many-winding-up-petitions-does-hmrc-present.html)). If the company still has a chance, the best protection against a PLN is to stop the National Insurance arrears growing and deal with HMRC before it petitions: see [how to stop an HMRC winding-up petition](https://directoraid.co.uk/how-to-stop-an-hmrc-winding-up-petition.html). Your duties change once the company is insolvent: see [my company is insolvent: what are my duties?](https://directoraid.co.uk/directors-duties-insolvent-company.html).

![Limited liability: where it stops. Each rung is a way the law reaches a director personally.](https://directoraid.co.uk/handbook-diagram-exposure-ladder.png)
*From [The Winding-Up Petition Handbook](https://directoraid.co.uk/winding-up-petition-handbook.html), free for directors.*

### Key points

- A PLN makes a director personally liable for a company's unpaid National Insurance where the failure was due to the director's fraud or neglect (section 121C).
- It covers NICs and interest only, not VAT, PAYE income tax or corporation tax.
- HMRC must prove fraud or neglect; the burden is on HMRC on every ground of appeal.
- There are four statutory grounds of appeal, and the deadline is short.
- An unpaid PLN can be enforced against you personally, including by bankruptcy.

### Frequently asked questions

**Can HMRC make me pay my company's National Insurance?** Only by a personal liability notice, and only where the company's failure to pay is attributable to your fraud or neglect.

**Can a PLN be issued after the company is liquidated?** Yes. PLNs are commonly issued after the company has entered liquidation or administration, when the arrears cannot be collected from the company.

**What if there are two directors?** HMRC can serve notices on each culpable officer and split the amount according to its view of each officer's culpability; you can appeal the proportion as unreasonable.

**Does a PLN cover VAT or PAYE income tax?** No. It covers National Insurance contributions and interest; HMRC's other powers, such as joint and several liability notices, are separate.

---
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition: text DIRAID to 82228, phone 07361 999123, email help@directoraid.co.uk, or book at https://calendly.com/directoraid/consultation.
