# Can a company in a CVA get a winding-up petition, and what happens if the CVA fails?

Source: https://directoraid.co.uk/winding-up-petition-company-in-cva.html · Last reviewed 2026-11-06 · Director Aid

**Yes. A CVA binds the creditors it covers, but it does not protect the company from new creditors, and if the company defaults and the CVA fails, the supervisor will usually petition to wind it up. Missed CVA contributions or unpaid new tax are the most common causes. A failing CVA can sometimes be varied, but a petition then follows its own timetable.** Directors also ask "what happens if a CVA fails?", "can HMRC petition while we are in a CVA?" and "can a CVA creditor wind up the company?". This page sets out who can petition, what happens to the money already paid, and what you can still do.

### Who can petition against a company in a CVA

| Creditor | Can it petition while the CVA is running? |
|---|---|
| A creditor bound by the CVA, for the debt the CVA covers | Generally not while the arrangement is in force and being performed: its rights are governed by the CVA's terms, and it looks to the supervisor. What it can do on a default depends on those terms. |
| The supervisor | Yes. Section 7(4) Insolvency Act 1986 allows the supervisor to petition, and most CVAs require the supervisor to consider petitioning, or proposing administration, if a default is not put right. |
| A creditor whose debt arose after the CVA was approved | Yes, in the ordinary way, if it is owed more than £750 and is unpaid. New suppliers, new landlords' arrears and new tax are not covered by the arrangement. |
| A secured or preferential creditor that did not agree to be bound | Its rights are not affected by the CVA without its consent (section 4(3) and (4)), so it can enforce them. |

HMRC is the creditor most likely to petition. Its debts for the period before the CVA are usually in the arrangement, but tax that falls due afterwards (VAT, PAYE and corporation tax) has to be paid on time, and CVA terms commonly treat a failure to pay or file as a default. HMRC presents most winding-up petitions in England and Wales ([how many winding-up petitions does HMRC present?](https://directoraid.co.uk/how-many-winding-up-petitions-does-hmrc-present.html)).

### How a CVA fails

1. **A default.** The company misses a monthly contribution, falls behind with new tax, fails to file returns, or breaks another term of the proposal.
2. **A default notice.** The supervisor usually writes to the company setting out the breach and giving a period to put it right. This is the moment to act.
3. **A variation, if one is possible.** Many CVAs allow the supervisor to put a variation to creditors, for example lower contributions or a longer term, if trading has changed. Creditors vote on it.
4. **Termination.** If the default is not remedied and no variation is approved, the supervisor issues a certificate or notice that the arrangement has failed, and tells the creditors and Companies House.
5. **The petition, or another process.** The supervisor petitions for winding-up, or the company goes into administration or creditors' voluntary liquidation. If a compulsory order is made, the Official Receiver becomes liquidator.

**DO NOT ignore a default notice. In most CVAs it starts a short period in which the default can still be remedied or a variation proposed; once the arrangement is terminated those options usually go.**

### What happens to the money already paid in

The answer depends on the CVA's terms. Most provide that money and assets the supervisor holds for the CVA creditors are held on trust for them, so they are paid out to those creditors even after the arrangement fails, rather than going into the liquidation for everyone. In the liquidation, the CVA creditors can usually claim the balance of their original debts after giving credit for what they received. New creditors share in whatever the liquidator then realises.

### If a petition was presented before the CVA

A proposal for a CVA does not automatically stop a pending petition. The court will usually adjourn the hearing to let the creditors vote only if it sees a proposal prepared with an insolvency practitioner's support, not just an intention to make one. If the CVA is approved and binds the petitioner, the petition is normally dismissed or withdrawn. If the creditors reject it, the hearing goes ahead. Payments out of the company's property after presentation are void if a winding-up order follows unless the court validates them (section 127). See [what a CVA is and how one is approved](https://directoraid.co.uk/what-is-a-company-voluntary-arrangement-cva.html) and the [glossary entry on CVAs](https://directoraid.co.uk/glossary-company-voluntary-arrangement.html).

### Responding to a petition against a company in a CVA

The usual responses to a petition apply, with a few differences:

- **A petition by a new creditor.** Pay it, agree terms, or dispute it if there is a genuine dispute. Tell the supervisor at once: a petition is often itself a breach of the CVA's terms. See [how to stop a winding-up petition](https://directoraid.co.uk/how-to-stop-a-winding-up-petition.html).
- **A petition by a CVA creditor on the old debt.** Check whether the CVA is still in force and whether the creditor is bound. If it is bound and the arrangement is being performed, the petition may be open to challenge. See [disputed debts](https://directoraid.co.uk/disputed-debt-winding-up-petition.html).
- **A petition by the supervisor.** The supervisor petitions in the CVA creditors' interests. If the business can still be saved, put concrete figures to the supervisor quickly; otherwise consider whether an administration or voluntary liquidation would serve the creditors better than a compulsory order. See [can I liquidate after a winding-up petition?](https://directoraid.co.uk/close-the-company-after-a-winding-up-petition.html)

### What it means for you personally

A failed CVA that ends in liquidation or administration brings the investigation that a CVA does not. The liquidator or administrator must report on the directors' conduct, and will look at how the company traded during the CVA: whether new debts, especially tax, were run up when you knew the arrangement could not be met. That is the territory of [wrongful trading](https://directoraid.co.uk/wrongful-trading-directors.html) and, in serious cases, [disqualification](https://directoraid.co.uk/director-disqualification-compulsory-liquidation.html). Personal guarantees usually survive a CVA and are called on when the company fails. See [defending a personal guarantee claim](https://directoraid.co.uk/defending-a-personal-guarantee-claim.html).

**DO NOT keep trading on the back of unpaid new tax in the hope that the CVA will recover. If the arrangement cannot be met, take advice before the default, not after the petition.**

![The options compared.](https://directoraid.co.uk/handbook-diagram-options-grid.png)
*From [The Winding-Up Petition Handbook](https://directoraid.co.uk/winding-up-petition-handbook.html), free for directors.*

### Key points

- A CVA binds the creditors it covers, but new creditors and HMRC for new tax can petition in the ordinary way.
- Most CVAs require the supervisor to consider petitioning, or proposing administration, if a default is not remedied.
- A default notice usually gives a short window to remedy the breach or propose a variation.
- Money the supervisor holds is usually held on trust for the CVA creditors, even after failure.
- A failed CVA ending in liquidation or administration brings a review of the directors' conduct during the CVA.

### Frequently asked questions

**What happens if a CVA fails?** The supervisor issues a notice that it has failed and usually petitions to wind the company up, or the company goes into administration or voluntary liquidation instead.

**Can HMRC petition while we are in a CVA?** Yes for tax that fell due after the CVA was approved, and missing new tax is often a default under the CVA itself.

**Can a CVA creditor wind up the company?** Not generally for the debt the CVA covers while the arrangement is in force and being performed; on a default, what it can do depends on the CVA's terms, and the supervisor usually acts.

**Can a failing CVA be rescued?** Sometimes, if the supervisor and creditors agree to a variation before the arrangement is terminated, which is why a default notice should be dealt with straight away.

---
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition: text DIRAID to 82228, phone 07361 999123, email help@directoraid.co.uk, or book at https://calendly.com/directoraid/consultation.
