It can, if the cross-claim is genuine, serious and equal to or greater than the petition debt. The court treats a genuine cross-claim of that size in the same way as a disputed debt: the petition should not be allowed to proceed, because the net position between the parties is uncertain and winding-up proceedings are not the place to decide it. A cross-claim that is speculative, far smaller than the debt, or produced for the first time after the petition arrived will not help.
What the court looks for
- A genuine claim: a real legal basis, for example damages for late or defective performance, an unpaid invoice of the company's own, or a breach of the contract under which the petition debt arose.
- Serious and substantial: not fanciful, with evidence that would survive scrutiny.
- Amount: at least equal to the petition debt, or large enough that, net of it, the undisputed balance would not found a petition.
- Timing: a claim raised in correspondence before the petition carries far more weight than one assembled afterwards.
The cross-claim does not have to arise from the same contract, although it usually does, and it does not have to have been the subject of a court claim, although issuing one strengthens the position.
What happens if it succeeds
The petition is dismissed, often with costs against the petitioner, and the two claims go to the County Court or the High Court to be decided together in the ordinary way. The petitioner's debt does not disappear; it is netted off against the company's claim when both are decided.
What to do now
- Quantify the cross-claim properly, with the documents: contract, correspondence, evidence of loss.
- Write to the petitioner setting it out and requiring withdrawal of the petition.
- If refused, apply to restrain advertisement and dismiss, before the advertisement date, with a witness statement exhibiting the evidence.
- Consider issuing the company's own claim at the same time.
Where this is covered in more depth
Disputed debts and the Handbook's Chapter 7.
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition. Call 07361 999123, text DIRAID to 82228, or request a call back.
Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.
Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back
Or call us on 07361 999123
First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose
