It depends whether the whole debt is wrong or only part of it. If the whole debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, with evidence that predates the petition, the petition is an abuse of process and the company can apply to restrain advertisement and have it dismissed with costs. If part of the debt is undisputed and that part is itself enough to found a petition, the dispute over the balance will not stop the petition: the usual course is to pay the undisputed part, from third-party funds, and then treat the rest as a dispute.
What counts as a genuine dispute
The goods were defective, late or never supplied; the price was never agreed or is wrongly calculated; the invoice relates to a contract the company says it never made or lawfully ended; the debt has been paid in full or in part; the company has a genuine cross-claim worth at least as much. The dispute must be real, raised in good faith and supported by evidence, and a dispute documented before the petition is far stronger than one raised for the first time after it.
The undisputed balance
Suppose the petition is for £20,000, of which £12,000 is plainly owed and £8,000 is contested. The £12,000 alone would support a petition, so the court will not stop it because of an argument over the £8,000. Pay the £12,000, with the petitioner's costs to date, from a director's or third party's funds, with a letter making clear that the balance is disputed, and the petition is left standing on a disputed debt alone.
Interest, charges and costs
Contractual interest and late-payment charges are often added without the right to them being checked. Challenge them in writing, but do not rely on them alone: a petition for a debt that is owed, with the interest overstated, is still a petition for a debt that is owed.
What to do now
- Reconcile the claim line by line against the contract, the invoices and the payment records.
- Write to the petitioner's solicitors setting out exactly what is disputed and why, with the documents, and asking for the petition to be withdrawn or, if part is undisputed, offering payment of that part.
- If they refuse, apply to the court to restrain advertisement and dismiss, before the advertisement date.
- Ask for costs.
Where this is covered in more depth
Disputed debts and the Handbook's Chapter 7 and second worked example.
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition. Call 07361 999123, text DIRAID to 82228, or request a call back.
Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.
Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back
Or call us on 07361 999123
First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose
