DIRECTOR AID
WINDING-UP PETITION?

How to stop an HMRC winding-up petition

Confidential help for company directors facing a winding-up petition. Your first consultation is free: you have nothing to lose.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123 or request a call back

No costNo obligationCompletely confidential
Director Aid crest FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★
Director Aid is a private advisory service. We are not connected with the court, HM Courts & Tribunals Service, any petitioner or the Official Receiver.

Director Aid › Winding-up petitions

An HMRC winding-up petition is stopped in one of five ways, in this order of likelihood: pay the debt and HMRC's costs in full; put a credible time-to-pay proposal to HMRC's solicitors in writing before the hearing; challenge the figures where they rest on estimated assessments or missing returns; dispute liability where there is a genuine dispute; or take the company into administration or a voluntary arrangement where the business is viable. HMRC is the most frequent petitioner in England and Wales and runs its petitions to a system. The company that understands the system and acts in the first week after service has a far better chance than the one that turns up at the hearing hoping to negotiate.

HMRC petition served on your company? Free initial consultation with a Solicitor: call 07361 999123 or text DIRAID to 82228.

Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose

Why an HMRC petition is different

A trade creditor presents a petition because it wants paying and will usually talk. HMRC presents its petitions through its Enforcement and Insolvency Service and its solicitors, and behaves differently in four ways.

  1. It is a volume petitioner. The petition is one of many in the same court list. The decisions are made beforehand, on paper.
  2. It rarely negotiates at the hearing. HMRC's advocate attends with instructions. An offer made in the corridor almost never changes them.
  3. Its figures can be wrong. Where VAT, PAYE or corporation tax returns have not been filed, HMRC raises estimated assessments or determinations and petitions on them. The petition debt may then bear little relation to what the company actually owes.
  4. Its solicitors act on instructions and expect proposals in writing. A proposal sent to them in writing, with evidence, before the hearing is passed to HMRC for a decision. Anything else is not.

The general position is set out in HMRC has presented a winding-up petition against my company. This page is about stopping it.

1. Pay in full, with costs

Payment of the petition debt, interest and HMRC's costs is the route that works every time, if the money exists. HMRC's solicitors will give you the exact figure on request. Once paid, HMRC applies to withdraw the petition with the court's permission if it has not yet been advertised, or asks for it to be dismissed at the hearing.

Two points of care. Payments from the company's own account after presentation are void if a winding-up order follows unless the court validates them, so payment from a director's or a third party's own funds is usually cleaner; see can I stop a petition by paying the debt? And HMRC will want to know about other liabilities and outstanding returns before it withdraws; a later quarter left unpaid can produce a second petition within months.

2. A time-to-pay proposal made before the hearing

HMRC will sometimes agree not to oppose an adjournment where a credible time-to-pay proposal is made before the hearing. Each of those words carries weight.

If HMRC accepts, the usual outcome is an adjournment while the instalments are paid, not a withdrawal. HMRC rarely agrees a second adjournment. A missed instalment usually means HMRC asks for an order at the next hearing. The detail is in can a time-to-pay arrangement stop an HMRC petition? and will HMRC accept instalments after a petition?

3. Challenge the figures

Where the petition debt is built on estimated assessments or determinations because returns were not filed, the first step is to file the returns. Until they are filed HMRC's estimate stands as the debt and the court will treat it as such. Once accurate returns are in, the true liability replaces the estimate, which may reduce the petition debt substantially, sometimes to a figure the company can pay at once.

Filing late returns does not stop the petition by itself; it converts guesswork into a known figure that can then be paid or made the subject of a proposal. Do it immediately, through your accountant, and send HMRC's solicitors confirmation of what has been filed.

4. Dispute liability

A petition cannot properly be used to collect a debt that is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds, and that applies to HMRC as to anyone else. But a dispute with HMRC usually belongs in the tax tribunal, and the court will want to see that it is real: an appeal lodged, a review requested, correspondence showing the point was raised before the petition. A company that has filed no returns, lodged no appeal and simply says the figure is wrong is not disputing the debt in the sense that matters. Where a genuine dispute exists about the whole debt, the court can dismiss the petition with costs against HMRC; where it concerns part only, and the undisputed part is more than £750, the petition usually proceeds on that part. See disputed debts.

5. Administration or a company voluntary arrangement

If the company cannot pay, cannot propose terms it can keep and has no dispute, the question becomes whether the business is worth saving. Once a petition has been presented the company and its directors cannot appoint an administrator out of court; an administration order has to be sought from the court, although a lender with a qualifying floating charge can still appoint. A proposed company voluntary arrangement can lead the court to adjourn the petition while creditors vote, and HMRC will often decide the vote. Both need an insolvency practitioner. See administration to stop a winding-up petition.

What HMRC will not do

What to send HMRC

The proposal, in writing to HMRC's solicitors, with:

  • The proposal itself: the amount paid now, the instalments, the dates, and the date the debt is cleared.

  • A cash-flow forecast for the period of the proposal, showing the instalments and current tax paid as they fall due.

  • What caused the arrears: a bad debt, a lost contract, a seasonal trough. One honest paragraph.

  • What has changed: the new contract, the cost cut, the director's loan. HMRC is deciding whether this time is different.

  • Confirmation that all returns are filed and that current liabilities will be paid on time.

The deadline calculator gives you the dates for your petition. The routes that apply to every petitioner are in how to stop a winding-up petition.

Key points

  • HMRC decides on paper, before the hearing. Proposals go in writing to its solicitors, with evidence and preferably a payment on account.
  • Payment in full with costs always works; a credible time-to-pay proposal made in good time often leads to one adjournment, rarely a second.
  • Where the petition rests on estimated assessments, file the returns first: the true figure may be far lower.
  • A dispute about liability belongs in an appeal or review; an unparticularised objection is not a dispute.
  • HMRC will not hold off advertisement on a promise or accept instalments at the hearing with nothing paid.

Frequently asked questions

Will HMRC withdraw the petition if I pay the tax but not its costs? No. HMRC expects its costs of the petition to be paid as well, and the court will not usually dismiss or permit withdrawal while they remain outstanding.

Can I just ring HMRC and agree a payment plan? Not once a petition has been presented. The helpline cannot deal with a debt that is with the Enforcement and Insolvency Service; the proposal has to go to HMRC's solicitors in writing.

What if HMRC's figure includes estimated assessments for returns I have not filed? File the returns now. The actual liability then replaces the estimate, and a petition for a figure the company has shown to be wrong is far easier to deal with.

Tell us what is happening

Your first consultation is free, with no obligation: you have nothing to lose. Give us a few details and we will call you back. Everything you tell us is confidential.

Sorry, that didn't send. Please check your name, company and a phone number or email, and try again, or call 07361 999123.

We use these details only to contact you about your enquiry. See our privacy notice. Prefer to talk now? Call 07361 999123 or text DIRAID to 82228.

FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★

Your first consultation is free.

Book a 30-minute phone call at a time that suits you, weekdays between 10am and 4pm, and we will call you. Or email us with your company name and, if you have it, the petition's case number.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

help@directoraid.co.uk

Everything you tell us is treated in confidence.