An adjudicator's decision is binding until the dispute is finally decided by the court or arbitration, and the courts enforce it summarily, so a petition founded on an unpaid award is very hard to resist on the ground that the award is wrong. The limited grounds are that the adjudicator had no jurisdiction or acted unfairly, that the award has been paid or set off against a later decision, or that the company has a genuine cross-claim that could not have been raised in the adjudication and that equals or exceeds the award. A contractor that disagrees with an award should pay it and pursue the dispute to a final determination, not wait for the petition.
Why adjudication awards are different
The Construction Act's scheme is pay now, argue later. A party that loses an adjudication must pay the sum awarded even if it intends to challenge the result in court or arbitration. A petition founded on the unpaid award is therefore not a petition on a disputed debt in the ordinary sense: the debt has been decided, provisionally, by a tribunal both parties agreed to.
Grounds that can work
- Jurisdiction or natural justice: the adjudicator decided something outside the referral, or did not give the company a fair chance to respond. These are narrow and need advice quickly.
- Set-off against a later award: where the company has itself obtained an adjudication decision in its favour, the two may be netted.
- A genuine cross-claim that could not have been raised in the adjudication and exceeds the award.
- Payment or settlement of the award.
Grounds that do not
That the adjudicator got the facts wrong; that the final account will show a different figure; that the employer upstream has not paid. The chain is not a defence: the company's claim is against the employer, not the petitioning subcontractor or supplier.
The company's own position
Where the company itself is owed money under the same or another contract, start the adjudication or the claim now. A decision in the company's favour changes the position with the petitioner and is often the route to a settlement in which the petition is withdrawn.
What to do now
- Take advice at once on jurisdiction and natural justice; the window to raise them is short.
- If the award stands, pay it (from third-party funds if the company's own position is uncertain) and pursue the final determination.
- Start the company's own adjudication where there is a claim.
- Use a validation order to keep the sites running while this is resolved.
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition. Call 07361 999123, text DIRAID to 82228, or request a call back.
Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.
Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back
Or call us on 07361 999123
First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose
